Right off the bat, it might not seem like a marital dispute between a couple of on-line personalities has anything to do with my commute. And I admit it’s kind of a stretch, but let me explain. Sometimes during the six-and-a-half miles that I’m on the Greenway, I put in earbuds and listen to an audiobook or a podcast. I’d prefer, in theory, to be alone with my thoughts, or to be grounded in the moment, observing the world around me, but sometimes in actual practice I find that I want to drown out my thoughts. And then I will pop in the earbuds and listen to something.
After I discovered the There and Back Again podcast, I listened to The Lord of the Rings (checked out from RB Digital), and then listened to the podcast discussion about it. It’s almost done — I waited until he finished The Two Towers before I started Return of the King. That was months ago now (it was cold and I was still biking before my accident when I finished it). He’s almost done with the discussion — no spoilers, but there’s only a couple chapters left, to discuss.
The same guy was doing a Harry Potter podcast, and I listened to that with my daughter. It was a great activity for car trips — when we drove down to Nebraska for the eclipse, and later up to Glacial Lakes State Park* last fall, we listened to it on the road, and it made the miles fly by. When I went out of town for work, I called her from the hotel and we listened to it together. When he finished book four, I started reading Order of the Phoenix so I’d be ready when he started, which he did, just a few weeks ago.
And now he’s quit.
And I’m crushed; we both are.
His own statement is that he screwed up his marriage and his ex is posting lies about him, and that in response he’s taking himself out of the public eye. Which seems unfair; why punish us for what his wife says, was my initial response.
So I read up on what she says. She says he raped her. And she says he lied to her, manipulated her, psychologically abused her, cheated on her, had a secret life and used her nickname for him as the name of his podcast. I’m not quite sure why that last is supposed to offend, but there it is.
Anyway, it sounds like he’s pretty bad.
But I do think it’s okay to weigh what a man says in public along with what he does in private. If I learn that he’s a jerk — for now, I’m just talking about if a guy’s a jerk, and I’ll come back to the worse details later — but he’s still talking a good game — still talking about race and gender in the context of these books, and still talking about the social and political climate today in a positive and thoughtful way, does his being a private asshole negate the good he does? Some people will say yes, but I don’t agree. I think we are all complex individuals — we contain multitudes, as they say. And since none of us is 100% good or 100% bad, I’m not going to judge a man solely on one aspect of his life.
But we’re talking rape and abuse, here. And in my world, I believe when a woman stands up and reports a rape or abuse. Law enforcement statistics (I don’t know how they get these numbers) tell me that false reports of rape are pretty rare (though not unheard of). I don’t watch Cosby anymore because he disgusts me; do I want my daughter’s childhood to be spent listening to a man who is a closet rapist, the way I did? I adored Cosby. We had two or three of his albums and listened to the, over and over; I had some of those stories practically memorized. Finding out the truth about him was like losing abig chnk of my childhood.
So I went back the next day and read a little more about what Stephens’s ex-wife had to say. And what I found is that in addition to her fourteen point manifesto or whatever, she also has posted a continuous stream of tweets exhorting her fans to call him out on social media. But call him out with kindness, she tells her fans. Approach him like someone you care about, she says.
She says her husband gaslighted her throughout her marriage, and then she gaslights her fans. She pretends to be a kind and forgiving person, who just wants to help him be a better person, while all the while organizing a barrage of online harassment that has destroyed his career.
I haven’t figured out yet what I’m going to tell my kid about all this.
I’m really glad to be living in an era where women can stand up and speak publicly about rape, abuse, and harassment. I’m glad to be raising my daughter in an error where there are words for the things that happen to women, and where she is learning tools to defend herself.
But not all abuse is equal. Harvey Weinstein and Bill Cosby aren’t equal to Al Franken. Lives are being ruined and careers destroyed on the basis of a word. And when Lani Rich organizes a group of online vigilantes to systematically harass and abuse her ex-husband, and ultimately destroy his career, I don’t know that she’s making the world a better place.
Meanwhile, I’ve got six-and-a-half miles of straightaway ahead of me. And damn, I miss listening to those podcasts.
Tips for other literary discussion podcasts welcome.
Thanks.